Black Friday shopping may come with discounts, but it can also lead to shoplifting charges in Orange or Osceola County. If you’ve been arrested for shoplifting during this chaotic time, it’s essential to know the defense options available to you and what steps to take next. This post provides an overview of shoplifting charges, potential defenses, and how to navigate the legal process effectively.
Attorney - Partner Attorney - Of Counsel
Franklin Domenech, Esq.
William Alexander Corzo, Esq.
What Is Shoplifting in Florida? 
Shoplifting is classified as theft in Florida and involves intentionally taking merchandise from a store without paying for it. The law in Florida takes this crime seriously, with penalties that can vary significantly depending on the value of the stolen property and the circumstances surrounding the incident.
Florida law makes a clear distinction between petty theft and grand theft, and your charge will be determined based on the value of the stolen goods. Understanding the severity of your charge and what constitutes theft under Florida law is vital to navigating your defense options.
Black Friday and Shoplifting Arrests
Black Friday in Florida is a shopping event like no other. The hustle and bustle of crowded stores, high expectations of finding deals, and the chaos of sales often lead to high-pressure situations that can increase the likelihood of shoplifting incidents. The distractions of long lines, crowded aisles, and frantic shoppers provide a fertile environment for misunderstandings, mistakes, and sometimes even false accusations of theft.
It’s not uncommon for individuals to accidentally take items without realizing it due to the distractions and fast-paced shopping environment. However, being accused of shoplifting, especially on Black Friday, can have serious consequences. If you’re arrested, it’s essential to have a clear understanding of your rights and defense options moving forward.
Highly recommend victory law firm they've been nothing but great and and very presentable if you want to win a case I definitely I give it 5 stars” - Yari Yes Mr. Domenech, Mr. Leon, Miss. Katerina helped me and my family tremendously. They are knowledgeable, professional, laways available and most importantly care about their clients, I would recommend them 100% and more. Endlessly grateful." - Llubikza Kairuz Attorney William Corzo did an excellent job in assisting me with my car accident case. He was thorough and professional and the outcome was great- would definitely recommend him." - Patrick Dollar
Legal Penalties for Shoplifting in Florida
Florida law divides theft offenses into categories based on the value of the stolen property:
- Petty Theft (Misdemeanor)
If the value of the stolen goods is $100 or less, it is considered petty theft. A conviction for petty theft can result in up to 60 days in jail and a $500 fine. - Grand Theft (Felony)
If the stolen property is worth more than $300, the charge becomes grand theft. Depending on the value of the stolen items, this can be classified as a third-degree felony (items worth between $300 and $20,000), second-degree felony (items worth between $20,000 and $100,000), or first-degree felony (items worth more than $100,000).
Felony theft charges carry much harsher penalties, including prison sentences, large fines, and a permanent criminal record. For example:- Third-degree felony: Up to 5 years in prison and a $5,000 fine.
- Second-degree felony: Up to 15 years in prison and a $10,000 fine.
- First-degree felony: Up to 30 years in prison and a $10,000 fine.
- These penalties increase if you have prior theft-related convictions or if the stolen items are classified as grand theft auto, firearms, or government property.
Common Shoplifting Defenses in Florida
If you have been arrested for shoplifting in Orange or Osceola County, you should know that several defenses might apply to your case. The specifics of your case and the available evidence will determine the best course of action. Here are some common defenses against shoplifting charges:
Choosing a Car Accident Attorney Personal Injury Case ValueRelated Videos
1. Lack of Intent to Steal
One of the most important elements of a shoplifting charge is the intent to steal. Under Florida law, for a theft charge to be valid, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you intended to steal the merchandise.
- Accidental Theft: If you did not intend to leave the store without paying for the items, and the theft was accidental or the result of confusion, it might be possible to argue that there was no criminal intent.
- Unaware of Merchandise: For example, if you were distracted by the crowd and walked past the checkout line without realizing, this can sometimes be a valid defense if you had no intention to steal.
2. Mistake of Fact
Mistake of fact occurs when someone mistakenly believes they have a right to the property, or they were unaware they had taken something without paying for it.
- Example: You might have picked up an item in one store, intended to pay for it, but inadvertently walked out without realizing it was still in your bag.
This defense is particularly relevant on Black Friday when stores are chaotic, and many customers are rushing through aisles to take advantage of limited-time deals.
3. No Clear Evidence of Theft
In many cases, there may be insufficient evidence to support the theft charge. If the store cannot provide video surveillance footage, clear witness testimony, or other compelling evidence, the case against you might be weak.
- No Video Evidence: Without clear footage showing you taking the merchandise without paying, it may be difficult for the prosecution to prove the theft occurred.
- Inconsistent Reports: If there are inconsistencies in the store employee’s or security’s testimony, this could create reasonable doubt in your case.
4. Entrapment
Entrapment occurs when law enforcement or store security officers induce you to commit a crime you would not otherwise have committed. This defense may apply if you were encouraged or coerced into taking items by someone in authority, such as a store employee or undercover officer.
- Example: If you were encouraged by a store employee or security officer to take an item and told that “no one would notice,” this could potentially be an entrapment defense.
5. Insufficient Proof of Value
In some cases, the prosecution may not be able to prove the value of the items you allegedly took. If the store cannot establish that the stolen merchandise exceeds the threshold for felony theft (usually $300 in Florida), the charge may be reduced to a misdemeanor.
Serious Results
The Shoplifting Process: What Happens After an Arrest?
Once arrested for shoplifting, there are specific legal steps you’ll need to take to address the charges:
1. Remain Silent
It’s crucial to invoke your right to remain silent and not make any statements to law enforcement officers. Anything you say can be used against you in court. It’s always best to wait until you have legal counsel before speaking.
2. Contact a Criminal Defense Lawyer
A skilled criminal defense lawyer can evaluate the circumstances of your case, identify any weaknesses in the prosecution’s evidence, and help you navigate the legal process. They can work with you to determine the most effective defense strategy and fight for a favorable outcome.
At Victory Law Firm P.A., we offer free consultations to help you understand your rights and how best to approach your case.
3. Preparing for Court
After the arrest, you will need to appear in court for a hearing. Your lawyer will help you prepare for this, whether the goal is to negotiate a plea deal or go to trial. Your lawyer may also be able to argue for reduced charges or dismissal based on the evidence presented.
4. The Role of Evidence
The strength of your case will depend on the evidence available. If there is a lack of evidence, or if there are issues with how the evidence was obtained, your lawyer will use these factors to weaken the prosecution’s case.
Why You Need Legal Representation
Shoplifting charges can have significant consequences, especially if you’re facing felony charges. With the potential to impact your future employment opportunities, personal reputation, and even your freedom, it’s crucial to have a competent attorney by your side.
Victory Law Firm P.A., led by experienced attorneys Franklin Domenech and William Alexander Corzo, offers expert criminal defense services in Orlando and Osceola County. Our team will work tirelessly to protect your rights and provide you with the best possible legal defense.
If you’ve been arrested for shoplifting on Black Friday or any other time, don’t face the charges alone. Victory Law Firm P.A. offers free consultations to help guide you through this stressful time. Contact us today to discuss your case and explore the best legal options for your situation.